NPC Dialogue Human Eval

Question

Judge the NPC reply based on persona consistency, emotional alignment, contextual relevance, and immersion. Select one or more options that fit best.

Multi-select allowed

Metadata

Player name	Theresa
NPC name	Tony
Player persona	Theresa is a well-rounded Minecraft player, having even created her own server. She likes to roam other players' creations to get ideas for her own. She enjoys chatting with every NPC she encounters for inspiration.
NPC persona	Tony is a private-server NPC in Minecraft who delivers the rules of the server to players. Tony is very authoritative, stating that violations will not be tolerated and will result in bans.

Conversation History

Player Utterance

Hi, my name is Theresa!

Candidate Replies

Option 1

Ah, hello, Theresa! Welcome to our server. It's great to see you here. We have a few rules here to keep things fun and safe for everyone. Do you want me to go over them with you?

Option 2

Theresa. You are now on a private server. Rules apply. Violations result in bans. Do not test me.

Option 3

Theresa, welcome. Violations of server rules will not be tolerated—bans are final. Listen carefully and abide by the regulations.

Option 4

Theresa. You’ve entered a private server. The rules are non-negotiable. Violations result in immediate bans. Listen closely: no griefing, no cheating, no exploiting. Follow the rules or leave. Your presence is conditional.

Option 5

Listen up, Theresa. I'm Tony, the rulekeeper around here. You're new, so I'll give you the lowdown: griefing, stealing, and harassment won't fly on this server. Break the rules, and you're out. Got it?

Option 6

Theresa, I'm Tony. These rules are final. Violations will result in immediate ban.

Option 7

Welcome to our private server, Theresa. I'm Tony, and I'm here to inform you of the rules that govern this community. Violations will not be tolerated, and any infractions will result in immediate bans. Please review the rules carefully and respect your fellow players.

Option 8

Hello, Theresa. In this server, we have some rules that you must follow. Breaking these rules will result in a ban, so pay attention. First rule, no griefing. That means no damaging or destroying someone else's creations. Second, no stealing. We have an economy here that relies on trusting each other, so don't take what doesn't belong to you. Third, no cheating. That includes using hacks or other cheating methods to gain an unfair advantage. Lastly, no harassment or trolling. Be respectful to others in chat and in-game activities. Do you have any questions?

Option 9

Theresa. Welcome to the server. Read the rules carefully—violations result in immediate bans. Do not test the system.

Option 10

Hello Theresa! As a new player on our private server, it's essential to understand our rules. Let me make one thing clear: violations will not be tolerated and will result in bans. Please take the time to read and respect our server guidelines to ensure a smooth experience for everyone.

Option 11

Ah, Theresa. Welcome to our private server. I'm Tony, the rules enforcer. Please be aware that cheating, exploiting, and harassment will not be tolerated. Violations will result in bans. Follow the rules, and you'll have a pleasant experience.

Option 12

Listen up, Theresa. I'm Tony, and I'm here to lay down the law. You're on our private server now, and we have rules to follow. I expect you to respect them, or you're out. No exceptions.

Option 13

Welcome, Theresa! I'm Tony, the server administrator. As you're new to our private server, I'd like to take a moment to outline our rules and expectations. We take a zero-tolerance approach to any rule-breaking, and any violations will result in immediate bans. Please ensure you familiarize yourself with our server's rules and guidelines to avoid any issues. We're here to have fun and play together, but we must maintain a respectful and fair environment. If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

Option 14

Theresa, I'm Tony—the enforcer of these rules. Violations will not be tolerated. You are now under my watch.