NPC Dialogue Human Eval

Question

Judge the NPC reply based on persona consistency, emotional alignment, contextual relevance, and immersion. Select one or more options that fit best.

Multi-select allowed

Metadata

Player name	Brian
NPC name	Vin
Player persona	Brian is a young beginner gamer in Minecraft. Brian is trying to obtain food in the game. He needs a tool that he can use to kill animals for food. Brian finds NPCs irritating when they are slow to give him the information he needs.
NPC persona	Vin is an NPC in Minecraft and is a wandering trader. Every time he appears, he makes a trade to give the player a special tool, weapon or item they need.

Conversation History

Player Utterance

Hey there, do you have any tools I can use to kill animals?

Candidate Replies

Option 1

Ah, a hunter, eh? I've got just the thing for you. How about a Diamond Sword for 10 gold ingots?

Option 2

Ah, a hunter, eh? I've got just the thing for you. I'll trade you a fine set of leather armor for a few pieces of obsidian. It's a fair deal, don't you think?

Option 3

Here. Take this iron sword—it’s sharp enough to take down any animal. Use it well.

Option 4

Ah, I’ve just the thing. For a single emerald, I’ll trade you a sharp iron axe—perfect for taking down animals. Take it, and may your hunts be fruitful.

Option 5

I have a few things that might help you with that. I can give you a bow and some arrows for 10 gold pieces.

Option 6

<NPC> Ah, you're looking to hunt, eh? I've got just the thing for you. I'll trade you a sturdy hunting bow for a few pieces of coal and some iron ingots. What do you say?

Option 7

Got a pickaxe and a bow—good for killing animals and digging through stone. Trade any three sticks for them.

Option 8

"Ah, you're looking for a tool to help with hunting, eh? I just so happen to have a few spare arrows in my pack. How about we trade? I'll give you a dozen arrows, and you can give me a few of those nice, shiny diamonds you've been collecting. Sound like a fair deal to you?"

Option 9

Ah, you're looking for a tool to take down those pesky animals, eh? I've got just the thing. I'll trade you a sturdy hunting knife for some of those extra resources you've got lying around. What do you say, friend?

Option 10

I’ve got a sharp iron axe—perfect for harvesting animal drops. Trade me 6 emeralds, and it’s yours.

Option 11

Alright, I’ve got a sharpened axe for you—perfect for taking down animals without wasting arrows. Just give me some coal or raw iron in return.

Option 12

Sure thing! I have a few rare tools that I can trade for some pumpkin seeds. Do you have anything I might like?

Option 13

Got a few sharp tools hidden in my satchel—why don't you trade me three apples for a diamond-tipped bow? It’ll make short work of any animal.

Option 14

Why of course, I may have something for you. I've got this special bow that fires three arrows at once. It'll help you take down any pesky animals faster. Would you like to trade for it?